You decide, read the article in the Shawnee Dispatch
http://www.shawneedispatch.com/news/2008/jun/25/dc_dinner_continues_stir_pot/
One additional point: When asked for verification that the liquor was on a separate bill Mr Pflumm basically said because he said so. Strange, when he has questioned others and would not take statements at face value (from citizens, city staff and even other council members) his favorite statement is "show me".